Most moments of my day make me cringe, replay, wish for a do-over, and overthink.
I am consumed with doing things exactly right. And doing my best is painfully short of that expectation.
I realize it’s silly to live in a black-and-white world in which perfection is somehow possible and always out of reach. I’ve read the books. I’ve heard the aphorisms. I know I should strive for shades of grey.
(Not that kind. That’s why I used the British spelling.)
Wanting precision is part of why I edit for a living. (Though not this blog, I’m always horrified to find. The typos in my writing, if collected, would actually kill any living grammarian.) It’s also why I have such high levels of self-imposed stress. Life is messy and imperfect and very grey. And that raises my blood pressure.
Raising my children, of all my jobs, has astronomically high stakes. Actions, both singly and cumulatively, affect who my children will be and how they see the world. Yes, personality is partially innate. There is nothing I can do to make a cautious and thoughtful guy silly and outgoing. Nor would I want to. There is not much I can do to make the impetuous and social guy reserved. Nor would I want to.
But I feel it’s my job to keep them safe and to teach them to do the same for themselves as they age. I don’t feel I have to protect my children from the forces fighting against them in the world. I feel I need to introduce those forces, explain them, and teach a few coping mechanisms. Gravity is there. It confounds climbing and wheeled motion. But you can work with gravity by learning and keeping your balance, listening to your body and to the structure on which you’re climbing. And if you can do that, you will skate (and climb) through life with minimal bruising and maximal enjoyment. The tree will tell you what’s safe. You just have to hear it telling you when to stop or change course.
There are real dangers in the world. Other than gravity. Machines and people can and will hurt you if you expose yourself to them at the wrong moment.
But my sense of danger is probably outsized, and my sincere desire to protect is probably overzealous.
And by “probably” I mean “way astronomically beyond acceptable.”
This morning, getting them into the car, I noticed that the first-grader’s seat belt was weird. One strap tightened securely but the other stayed loose. (Yes, for those of you keeping score, I keep him in a five-point harness. Still. And will until he reaches the height or weight maximum of his convertible booster. The two-and-a-half year old is still rear-facing, and will be until he reaches the height or weight limit for rear-facing. Some will mock, and some will nod their head in agreement. I don’t care. They’re my kids and as long as we have access to the safety equipment, I will use it.) Peanut usually does his own belt, but he fell yesterday climbing a bike rack that I told him was not an ideal place to climb. His thumb still hurts and I helped him buckle up.
I did not handle the wonky seat belt well. We were late. I *hate* being late. It makes me absolutely pulse with adrenaline. It makes me go into full “there’s a tiger chasing us, let’s GO” mode. I freaked out, reprimanding the big guy for not telling me before that it was loose, for probably fiddling with the adjustments too much, for not taking seat belts seriously enough…and then I cycled back through the admonitions. About a hundred times. “If the belt is loose you have to say something. If you loosen it for a jacket or other reason, you have to tighten it back down. Did I mention it’s a big deal? Did I mention you should notice it’s tighter on one side? Did I mention you can’t just adjust it willy nilly? Did I mention we’re late and I can’t fix it right now and I might just flip myself onto the ceiling from the stress right now?”
The entire eight minute drive to toddler school, I talked incessantly about how I wanted them safe and how hard it is to fit something unusual (like a wonky seatbelt that we should be able to count on but that has completely thwarted us with its inherently flawed nature) into our schedule and how important seat belts are and how being aware is most of safety and how oh my gawd the world is an unsafe and unpredictable place in which to live.
Ridiculous. Counter productive. Psychologically damaging. Asinine. Easily fixed. Harmful. Insane.
I could keep my mouth shut. I could detach the seat, disassemble all the belts and loops and buckles and start over. I could re-string the loops and buckles and belts, re-attach the seat, and make sure it’s perfect in less than ten minutes. (Seven, actually, which is how long it took after we kissed Butter goodbye and went outside to tackle the errant belt and show it who’s boss of this damned fragile planet.) I could let us be late and actually make them safe instead of lecturing about safety.
I know all that. But I’m a spazz. I’m naturally high strung. As in: strings breaking if you look at them, let alone try to make music from them.
And I live every minute with the reality that my basic nature makes me a shitty parent.
No child benefits from ten minutes of stress about safety because their mother is a spazz. No child needs all those neuroses spewed all over them. No child needs to think their mother is driving them in an unsafe seat because she can’t bear to be late and can’t take one deep breath and figure out how to fix things. No child needs a lecture on a loop for something they didn’t do, and had no reason to expect.
So. I taught my kids I’m dangerous in emergencies. I taught them to overreact about little dangers. I taught them to privilege being on time over safety. I taught them to lecture and reiterate instead of doing.
Basically, I taught them everything they don’t need to internalize.
I broke them, and they will be neurotic, maladjusted grownups. Because I’m a freak.
I didn’t yell. I didn’t hit. I didn’t call names. I used a quiet voice. And I did reassure the big guy even during the initial lecture that he probably didn’t do it and that I need to do a better job of checking the belt regularly.
But I damaged my kids just by being me. By trying so hard to do my best and by making the stakes so high, I hurt their perception of the world, themselves, and my ability to care for them.
I apologized during and after. I fixed the seat. I got them both to school on time. I never raised my voice or called names. I made it clear I was stressed about the situation not about them. But there was, in my hindsight, nothing good about how I handled it.
And I have spent my morning stewing and planning how to do better the next time. I want to apologize again and tell them again why I’m terrible and wrong and should have done better. But I blog so I can tell you, instead. Because what they least need is more mountain-of-molehilling. What they least need is neurotic “fixing” of already misanthropic behavior. What they least need is that version of me.
And the pain of that keeps me up at night.
This version of me, the one they should be spared, is inherently me. I can fight it and I can learn to cope and keep my mouth shut and breathe and find perspective. Even though I can’t change who they are and shouldn’t, I can try really hard and change who I am, right?
And can I do that before I pick them up today? Because I’d like them to only get the good sides of me. All the time. And only in just the right quantities so that they can be their best possible selves without me getting in the way.
That’s a reasonable, several-shades-of-grey kind of expectation, right?
I can totally picture this all happening. I say you and me take the seat to the shooting range and blow it to smitherines. Shoot first, aim later. It’s all good.
Those mini nuts need you, all of you, including the spazz, the neurotic, and the freak. Know why? It makes them feel normal. They can be a spazz, neurotic, and freak (like you), and it will be ok. It’s ALL OK. You did raise the stakes. They are learning it’s ok to flip out like I know you do! about Shit Gone Wrong. You got through it, and it’s over. All is OK with their world. Mommy lost her shit today. Mommy got it back. And when they lose their shit, they’ll get it back too.
I want several shades of shiny glitter.
How about 50 gradations of herky?
Thanks unicorn. Now I feel like I can actually lose my shit tomorrow. They ain’t seen nothin’ yet. ;-)
We are from the same cloth. It’s painful to read because it hits so close to my reality. I hate it. The part about how I will damage them by just being me? A ka-Pow to my heart. It’s how I feel. And I hope we are both wrong.
Of course we are. I think. Except I totally don’t.
I know for *sure* that we damage ourselves thinking that we’re damaging them.
And though I swore I’d use my blog as therapy and not trouble the lads with a rehash, I used the whole thing as a teachable moment this afternoon after asking Peanut what he thought about getting frustrated and driving with a wonky belt instead of taking the time to fix it. We both agreed I made a bad choice and should take a breath next time. Oxygen to the brain helps with better choices, I told him.
So might a lobotomy, but I’ll try the breathing first.
Thanks for writing the post and the comment replies. It resonates, and I am much more comfy reading about yours than writing about mine. I agree with unicorn – normalizing errant behaviour will make our kids resilient and forgiving. Reach around and give yourself a hug!
Chickadee, I’m happy to bare my ugly bits so we can all fee norma. Maybe not a reach around, but a little forgiveness, sure. ;-)
No. NO. NO.
You are not breaking them: you are giving them personality, quirks, making them interesting, giving them stories to tell about you when you’re gone that will make them smile with recollection.
YOU are making them have a vibrant life: where they learn idiosyncracies, acceptance, extending limits: reaching beyond what they know in their world.
YOU ARE GIVING US COLOR IN OUR LIVES.
(says me, whose teens are the most COLORFUL people she has EVER known)
This is what I think in my best moments. And what I think the other parents around me are doing for their kids. I just have a block about supposing it might be true for my kids. I’m too serious about the whole thing. Maybe I should parent for a day with a pair of toddler underpants on my head.
You’re sure not alone in feeling like a monumental screwup a lot of the time. Even while reading this post, which has lots to say about calming right the heck down and keeping priorities straight, my kids started squabbling and I tore out of the office yelling at them to stop. That paycheck’s not going to earn itself, you know, and I was super busy in here at work um reading your blog.
The kids’re gonna turn out great, and there’s so much more you could be doing so much worse, which I think is about the best most of us can manage.
Sir, I salute you. You know what I need? To reread Infinite Jest. Every single parent in that novel screws their kids so horrifically, an unwarranted lecture about seatbelts sounds like Parent of the Year.
Think of me as the Damaged in that book damage unto others as they have had damage done unto them.
As a fellow high-strung, neurotic freak, I understand. And don’t even ASK me how the “menstruation” talk went last night. Talk about a botched enterprise.
Oh, dear gawd, I don’t know which I’d handle more poorly: surprise safety issue that might make us late or totally expected but touchy “we all say congrats and mean it but really, what a pain, and please please please don’t get pregnant.”
Don’t have caffeine, is all I’m saying.
Ah, my friend, don’t be so hard on yourself! I have done the same thing over and over again. Only I use lots of swear words and lay on the guilt. And then I apologize… It’s the same pattern my dad used. I swore I’d never do it. Your boys will be great grown-ups; it’s important for them to know that we are human and we make mistakes. But it’s imperative for our kids to know that we can improve, just like they can. Hang in there.
Ah, dang it, I forgot I can get better and teach them about working hard to become the best you can. Thanks, Jay.
It’s the only idea that keeps me from self-flagellating (sp?) and keeps the beer industry in the black.
I’ve come to read your blog several times. I discovered you via Motherfog’s blog. Usually, I just read and don’t comment although I love your writing, commentary, wit, perspective, …Today, though, I just couldn’t leave without saying – your kids will grow up to be well-adjusted adults because you modeled how to lose it, process through it, gain control of it, and get over it. Transparent parenting is important so they learn how to do those things, too.
And the lecture on a loop – UGH – if only I could make myself close my mouth! I still don’t have great control of that and I have been at this parenting thing for 14 years! Sometimes while I’m talking at them all I hear in my mind is “Shut up! You need to stop! What are you doing?” I do think I am making progress, though.
Thanks, Rita. Thank you so much.
I’m really glad they can’t hear the “what the hell is wrong with you”s in my head. Because all that’s wrong is that they’re not adults. Which drives me NUTS but seems reasonable, given their age. ;-)
This strikes a chord: “I damaged my kids just by being me.”
I think we all damage our kids, sometimes in obvious ways, sometimes less so. Sometimes they tell us we hurt them, sometimes they don’t even get it until years later. But we can only do the best we can in the moment. We are damaged too, probably from our parents and they from theirs and so on. At least if we see it maybe we can work on our issues, and maybe even prevent them from fully becoming our kids’ issues. Maybe. I hope!
I hope so, too!
If we all get a bit kinder and more understanding than the previous generation, but the time the planet is inhospitable the kids are going to be flawless.
Some days are good–when your son says you’re a good helper. Some days are bad–when you see your worst self berating your kid. But on ALL days, you are the best mom you can be that day.
It’s quite clear you are very, very far from a shitty parent.
Thanks, Kristen. Why do I let the inner critic talk more than the “good helper” expert?
Every word of this I understand and live daily. The actions. The explanations. The discussions that are meant for the intellect of a college psych major. Im sure this isn’t comforting to you because you know better than any stranger should how crazy I am, but I had to let you know this made me feel not so crazy. And I needed that. Thank you for your humanity, your honesty when it comes to your humanity, and for the stellar job you’re doing at raising amazing humans. It’s the parents who don’t question thier every syllable and action, and believe they are doing it perfectly that are the shitty ones. At least, that is what I have written on my mirror.
I sincerely feel that my best moments writing are when I feel someone feel less crazy.
I have a feeling the parents who think they’re doing well probably are, the people who think they are doing terribly probably aren’t, and that as long as we’re not abusing our kids and are really trying our best, that’s all we can do.
Because I’ve tried for nigh on 40 years to do better than my best, and have never actually done it.
luckily, every day isn’t shit-tastic. i fucking hate trying to fix those damned safety seats. i have definitely thrown some fits over those things. hopefully the girls won’t remember the rants. but they probably will. there’s plenty more where that came from!
I’ve got a lot of everything, 2020. Fits, love, ideas, rules, cuddles, books, snacks….